07-13-2010, 11:36 PM
Generally, your actual app was good. From a technical and communication standpoint, I am impressed. CrazyD will be along eventually to point out that you failed on the armory link, but other than that, well done. There are adults who can't put together an app that doesn't look like complete garbage.
However, there are some very concerning things here.
You're specced Holy/Ret. Which is terrible and right off makes me wonder if you understand the class. You also went 1/2 BoW, which is pretty much a complete waste of a point. Imp BoW is very much an all or nothing talent.
Your gearing is atrocious. You have zero T10 and a a ton of Crit/MP5 pieces. Crit/MP5 is our very worst itemization and really should be avoided like the plague. 245 MP5/Haste items would be better than most of the 277 MP5/Crit you're wearing. Sometimes bad luck happens in gearing but there are plenty of Frost Badge options that are properly itemized that you have chosen not to get.
You are somehow below even the "soft cap" of Haste. You almost have to try to have only 440 Haste at this point. This is terrible.
These are basic tenants of our class that can be found with, literally, 20 seconds of internet searching. You are very much not performing up to our class's full potential.
Even if you were a decent app, we don't really have a spot for another Pally of any spec. As it is, you don't understand the Holy Pally class enough to be a benefit to our raid even if we needed one. If you want to learn more about the things you SHOULD be doing though, feel free to message myself or Jackslammer. Neither of us mind helping players out with our class.
Edit:
I missed the part where you said that you run with one of our PUGs. Honestly, I would recommend that we stop bringing you until you work on some of your core issues. You are being carried more than you are contributing to any raid you join at this point.
However, there are some very concerning things here.
You're specced Holy/Ret. Which is terrible and right off makes me wonder if you understand the class. You also went 1/2 BoW, which is pretty much a complete waste of a point. Imp BoW is very much an all or nothing talent.
Your gearing is atrocious. You have zero T10 and a a ton of Crit/MP5 pieces. Crit/MP5 is our very worst itemization and really should be avoided like the plague. 245 MP5/Haste items would be better than most of the 277 MP5/Crit you're wearing. Sometimes bad luck happens in gearing but there are plenty of Frost Badge options that are properly itemized that you have chosen not to get.
You are somehow below even the "soft cap" of Haste. You almost have to try to have only 440 Haste at this point. This is terrible.
These are basic tenants of our class that can be found with, literally, 20 seconds of internet searching. You are very much not performing up to our class's full potential.
Even if you were a decent app, we don't really have a spot for another Pally of any spec. As it is, you don't understand the Holy Pally class enough to be a benefit to our raid even if we needed one. If you want to learn more about the things you SHOULD be doing though, feel free to message myself or Jackslammer. Neither of us mind helping players out with our class.
Edit:
I missed the part where you said that you run with one of our PUGs. Honestly, I would recommend that we stop bringing you until you work on some of your core issues. You are being carried more than you are contributing to any raid you join at this point.