Up coming ICC melee TRINKET

[Keiku]

All the melee are good besides keiku anyways

also this topic shouldve been addressed after the actual loot is known.

[mininolan]

Im a little conflicted on this topic tbh.

Take for example... heroic Anub trinket. Went to a shadow priest. A shadow priest. Shadow. Priest. Not that the trinket is useless for the class by any means, but in terms of overall gains a mage, moonkin, ele shaman or dest lock would get more mileage out of it. But that's par for the course with a dkp system.

No matter which way loot is handled, someone will find something to bitch about. So in the end, no, leave our current loot system in place. DKP is being reset for ICC so no one is going to have any huge advantage when the time comes.


On the topic of wanting rolls even on the slightest of upgrades it appears I may severely go against the grain here. I for one would not blow a massive chunk of dkp on an item that would give me a 0.5% dps increase when I could, within reason, hold our for an item that would give me a 5% boost. As far as Im concerned, anyone who thinks Im wrong in doing that, can blow it out their ass. :angry-cussingblack: I have no problem what so ever in holding out for a larger upgrade, again, within reason.

I was recently top contender to grab the anub trinket. I had been, and would have continued to pass on upgrades providing 5-10 additional SP or Haste, etc., because the benefit did not outweigh the cost. Now when the beasts blade dropped, I rolled. It wasn't a small upgrade... it was a very large upgrade. It prevented me from obtaining a trinket which I so desperately need. But the cost:benefit ratio was worth it.

In any case, arguing about our personal feelings on how dkp should be spent is a worthless endeavor. We can either change the way we handle loot, or suck it the fuck up.

I WILL SAY I WAS FIRST IN LINE ON CASTER DKP GOING IN TO THAT RAID.......AND WHEN THE BELT DROPPED I KNEW THAT IT WAS BIS AND I HAD PASSED ON IT SEVERAL OTHER TIMES IN HOPES THAT THE ANUB TRINKET WOULD DROP OR THE TWINS NECK...........I wanted to kill myself....because had I kept whoring it wouldn't have gone to the shadow priest it would have gone to me. But shit happens i decided to go with a lesser upgrade but still a bis item. If I get another BIS this week, then it will have been worth it....instead of just whoring for the trinket.


love you tyrul

[Entrapment]

LAWLER I DON'T EVEN PLAY ON A MAC ANYMORE KEEP UP BUDDY

[Firecrest]

Sooo... You were gay, but now you're not? Was it basically just so you could tell your kids about "this one time in college"?

[Crazy Diana]

:gay-imgay: :angry-nono:

[abecx]

what if we make it so no item can cost more than 500DKP?

[Rosco]

That wasn't the issue, if they're gonna dkp whore they deserve to lose 1800 dkp.

It was really the benefit of the item towards a player that would use it to its max and not suck dps/not show up.

[lawlerbation the hardcore squatter]

LAWLER I DON'T EVEN PLAY ON A MAC ANYMORE KEEP UP BUDDY

MAYBE IF YOU EVER GOT ON VENT I WOULD KNOW WHATS UP

[Mikaelo]

what if we make it so no item can cost more than 500DKP?

IMO that would just make people whore out more. 'Well if I don't get it now it's still gonna cost 500DKP later, so I'll just save for that awesome item'

[Crazy Diana]

do it the way blizzard intended. turn on group loot